The Housing Problem: Scarcity and High Prices by Our Own Choice
Presentation
Spain's housing market fails, but its policies make those failures worse rather than correcting them. Restrictions on building, transferring and contracting produce scarcity and hurt above all those still looking for a home. On the supply side, buildable land is scarce by political decision: many citizens and groups can block a development without bearing its cost, urbanizing land takes ten to fifteen years, and taxes absorb about a quarter of what the buyer of a new home pays. High transfer taxes and comparatively light taxes on ownership penalize mobility and keep homes empty or underused. In the rental market, rent caps, mandatory extensions and obstacles to recovering a dwelling protect the sitting tenant at the expense of the prospective one, as owners withdraw supply and screen for solvency; for the 2020 Catalan regulation, rents fell by about 5 % while new contracts fell by about 10 %. Such policies pay electorally despite their social cost because current tenants and debtors see the immediate gain while future contracting parties barely perceive the lost opportunities, and survey microdata from Catalonia and Spain show that demand for protection tracks respondents' position in the housing market. The paper proposes five lines of reform: easing construction, rebalancing taxation away from building and transfers, restoring legal certainty and contractual freedom, funding assistance to vulnerable households with explicit public money instead of loading it onto landlords, and regulatory subsidiarity with transparent comparison of results. The main obstacle is political: voters reward restrictions whose costs stay hidden, so housing remains scarce and expensive.